County officials duplicated ballots at election day meeting

In North Carolina, county boards of elections meet on the afternoon of election day to tabulate early and absentee ballots. I had an opportunity to witness part of one such meeting on November 3. However, because of what transpired during the meeting, I was only able to witness a small part of it.

Getting to the meeting

The Franklin County Board of Elections (BOE) is located in Franklin Plaza, a strip mall in Louisburg, where it shares a storefront with other county government agencies. I entered the building shortly before the 3:00 meeting started.

Entrance to Franklin County government facilities in Franklin Plaza, Louisburg, North Carolina.

As soon as I entered the facility, I was greeted by several signs reminding voters that Franklin Plaza was not an election day voting site (it had been one of Franklin County’s four early voting sites). Despite that, I witnessed about a dozen people coming in to vote. The BOE set up a table just outside their door, staffed by a staffer with a computer, who instructed those voters on where their precinct polling places were located. By 3:45, she had provided such instructions to about 120 people.

Station outside the Franklin County Board of Elections office where a staffer informed voters where they should go to vote on election day. The staffer asked not to be in the picture and was standing just out of frame when it was taken.

Dealing with absentee ballots

The meeting began shortly after 3:00 with four of the board’s five members, with the fifth member joining shortly. I was one of two public observers. The other was a representative of the county Democratic Party on hand to collect information on the board’s decisions on absentee ballots (there was no Republican representative). Later in the meeting, BOE Executive Director Michelle Chavis reported that they had about a dozen absentee ballots that required curing, all but two of which had been cured.

The North Carolina State Board of Elections briefly explained absentee ballot curing in a November 4 media release:

All remaining absentee-by-mail ballots that have a curable deficiency will be counted on Tuesday, November 10, as long as the voter’s cure document is received by noon on that day. Curable deficiencies can include when a voter did not sign their ballot application or signed it in the wrong place, or there is an issue with the photo ID documentation included with their ballot application.

Duplicating ballots that could not be tabulated

Soon after the meeting started, Chavis reported to the board that four early voting ballots could not be read by tabulators, two each from the Franklin Plaza and Youngsville Armory sites. The board then prepared to duplicate the votes on those four ballots so that they could be read by tabulators and counted.

At that point, they voted to go into closed session since they would be reading out the votes from each ballot. They granted me permission to take pictures through the glass wall before they brought out the ballots in question. The board’s three Republican and two Democratic members worked together to duplicate the ballots.

Franklin County Board of Elections Executive Director Michelle Chavis (standing, right) and board members prepare to duplicate four ballots that could not be read by tabulators.

The board went back into open session about twenty minutes later. After hearing the aforementioned absentee ballot cure report, they paused the meeting for a pizza break since there was other business that they could not yet handle.

I would like to have stayed to witness more of the meeting, but I had election day promises to keep,
and miles to go before I sleep.